Post-game Reactions

As is our annual tradition here at CelticsHub, we dive into the full collection of predictions around the NBA postseason. While you will get a rundown of everyone’s thoughts later in the post, you’ll get the full Celtics-Knicks thoughts and a prediction from me (Brian Robb) to kick off things off.


So I’ve looked long and hard around the Internet right now, and I can’t find ANYONE outside of Boston predicting the Celtics will win this series. Whether it’s ESPN, CBS, SI, Yahoo!, there are countless smart and talented NBA writers who are counting out the Celtics. I respect that, I understand that, and it’s something Celtics fans have seen seemingly every year at this point.

What national people don’t realize though, is not all the local writers/analysts in Boston are homers, us here at CelticsHub included. We call it pretty straight around here and guess what? A lot of those guys, the people who see this team play pretty much every game, they’re going with the Celtics in this series. You can count me and the majority of the CelticsHub crew in that group. Knowing that, let me lay out my case for a Celtics upset, something pretty much no one outside Boston would sees coming.

1) Melo Factor. As Ryan pointed out earlier this week, you have three capable defenders in Jeff Green, Paul Pierce and Brandon Bass for Melo. Most teams don’t have that luxury (along with a Kevin Garnett waiting to help on the back line). Anthony hasn’t shot efficiently for years against the C’s, and this series should be no different. He’ll probably go off for a couple games, but he won’t win this series by himself.

2) 3-point shooting. What’s the answer to one of the best 3-point shooting teams in the league? How about Boston having the best 3-point defense in the league for the past four months since Avery Bradley has returned. Knicks shoot lights out at home, but Boston has the horses to keep them in check.

3) Boston’s recent “swoon”: The Celtics haven’t been playing well the last few weeks and everyone is pointing that out. They’re right, except there’s a pretty important thing the pundits are forgetting. Kevin Garnett has been out for a month. You can’t factor in anything this team does over that time span, especially defensively, without KG out there. The past month shouldn’t be held against them.

4) Injuries: For once, the Celtics are in better shape (relatively) than the Knicks (beyond the season-enders). KG, Pierce, and Terry have had ample time to rest up during the past few weeks. New York’s studs have rested as well this week, but their injuries appear to be more serious. Chandler and Martin haven’t played at all in weeks. There should be rust there for both guys and lingering concerns. Prigioni is doubtful for Game 1. There are two veterans signed this week that could very well get minutes in this series in Earl Barron and Quentin Richardson. I don’t care who you are, that’s not a good sign.

5) I don’t trust J.R. Smith or Raymond Felton to have four good games this series. Pretty simple on this one. Knicks need both of these guys firing on all cylinders to win the series. I’m not counting on it happening.

Put it all together and I like the C’s chances. Boston will struggle scoring at times, but the playoffs are more about defense than anything else and Boston has a serious advantage in that department. Throw in some added motivation for Paul Pierce and Kevin Garnett playing for a city that has been to hell and back in the past week and I’m not betting against them.

B Robb’s pick: Celtics in 6

The rest of our postseason picks…


Robb: Heat in 5. Giving Milwaukee a win in this series seems a bit generous, but the Bucks will find a way to steal one game when their dangerous 3-point shooters get hot. Milwaukee’s lackluster defense will be no match for LeBron James and the defending champions for the rest of the series, though.

Pina: Heat in 4. Even if LeBron James badly sprained his ankle warming up for Game 1, and wasn’t able to play throughout the series, the Milwaukee Bucks would still barely win one game. Back in reality, James is healthy and motivated to end this thing quickly so his team can rest up for either the Chicago Bulls or Brooklyn Nets.

Jackson: Heat in 5.  I love all the hubbub being made about Brandon Jennings saying the Bucks will take the series in six games?  What the hell is he supposed to say?  Unfortunately for Bucks fans, he is wrong. The Heat will steam roll the Bucks in 5 games. The Bucks steal one game on the back of Larry Sanders’ rim protection but then get blown out in the series clincher.

DeGama: Heat in 4. I’ve reluctantly backed away from my original pick of Heat in 3. This should be an evisceration, even if Miami takes a few quarters to get warmed up.


Robb: Pacers in 6. Indiana has struggled a bit down the stretch but can still clamp down defensively as well as any team in the league. The Hawks have an assortment of weapons on offense but lack the ability to score efficiently against an elite group like the Pacers.

Pina: Pacers in 5. The Indiana Pacers head into the playoffs winning just two of their seven April games. One of those losses was a very poor showing against the New York Knicks on the final Sunday of the regular season, and another was a blowout against the Washington Wizards. But I don’t care. These guys are bored. They’ll be borderline dominant on the defensive end against an Atlanta Hawks team that gave Devin Harris 25.3 minutes per game after the All-Star break.

Jackson: Pacers in 5.  In the past, the Hawks have relied on Joe Johnson and Josh Smith to make it hard on their opponent before eventually bowing out. This year’s iteration relies on Al Horford and Jeff Teague. Not bad bets if they’re your team’s respective third and fourth banana, but neither are players I would consider “go-to.” Meanwhile, the Pacers’ toughness will shine through quickly.

DeGama: Pacers in 6. The post-Joe Johnson Hawks will end up with a similar fate to the Joe Johnson Hawks: a tough, early round exit and one final year spent, wheels spinning, in neutral. Indiana’s league-leading defense will be the story of this series. Expect Atlanta to play with just enough edge to bring out the Pacers’ true nastiness.


Robb: Bulls in 7. Behind the improved play of Deron Williams, the Nets have started to show flashes of greatness that were expected, given the collection of talent they put together for this season. Unfortunately for Brooklyn, Chicago has the horses, especially on the front line, to slow down the Nets. The Bulls will struggle to score at times, but their excellent defense will prove to be the difference.

Pina: Nets in 7. Injuries (and frugal financial decisions) have been the undoing of Chicago Bulls basketball these last 11 months, and injuries will be their undoing in this playoff series. Joakim Noah and Taj Gibson are legitimate concerns, and with Derrick Rose presumably sitting this one out, Chicago lacks a single player who can go shot for shot with Deron Williams.

Jackson: Bulls in 7.  The Bulls’ mounting injury issues are scary to think about, but then you remember how good and tough the Bulls can be when they need to be. Deron Williams would have to average 30 ppg to take the series. He can, but he won’t.

DeGama: Nets in 7. The Bulls are a broke down engine but they’ll play enough defense to compete. They shouldn’t win three games against a Nets team that seems to have found itself, but Brooklyn is hardly a sure thing given their polarized year. The hope here is Deron Williams turns in a post-season that vaults him back into the “best PG in the league” conversation. He’s still capable of it.


Robb: Thunder in 5. This is as good of a 1-8 matchup as you can ask for, but too much firepower by Thunder.

Pina: Thunder in 6. If Omer Asik can average 40 minutes per game, stay out of foul trouble, plug every driving lane by physically transforming into a brick wall, not get tired, and find someone to defend competently when the Thunder go super small, the Rockets just might push this thing to 7.

Jackson: Rockets in 7.  BECAUSE I CAN!  No, seriously, how great would the story be if James Harden stood on his beard and averaged 40, 10, and 10?  This season’s also seen too many moments of the Thunder looking beatable. Between now and 1,000 pull up foul line jumpers from Russell Westbrook, the Rockets could come out on top.

DeGama. Thunder in 6. We all love the Rockets but no matter how I spin it in my head, I can’t see them winning more than two games. Even that feels generous. However, I am excited for the debut of James Harden, playoff supastah.


Robb: Spurs in 6. Given the Spurs’ struggles in the past couple weeks, this is closer than it should be, but Lakers will be too shorthanded to achieve the upset.

Pina: Spurs in 5. The Los Angeles Lakers barely defeated the San Antonio Spurs about a week ago. Barely. In that game, Tony Parker went 1-of-10 and was on the bench for 14 minutes. Neither of those things will ever happen again, let alone four times in seven games.

Jackson: Spurs in 5.  Can we stop pretending that the Lakers play defense and have a realistic chance to beating the Spurs? They will be out-classed quickly.

DeGama: Spurs in 5. Without Kobe Bryant, and with or without a decimated Steve Nash, the Lakers aren’t going to be able to consistently get good shots against San Antonio. The Lakers get one at home but the Spurs will carve them up with surgical precision.


Robb: Nuggets in 7. This would be a rout, but lots of Denver injuries make it closer. They’ll find a way.

Pina: Nuggets in 6. Kenneth Faried’s ankle makes me nervous. So does Stephen Curry’s wrist. Then I look at Golden State’s atrocious defensive frontcourt, Denver’s mile high air combined with the way they attack the rim like five grizzly bears charging Honeycomb’s international headquarters for 48 straight minutes, and Andre Iguodala guarding Curry in tight situations, and realize the Warriors hold the slightest of puncher’s chances.

Jackson: Nuggets in 6.  It sucks that both these teams can’t win. I want this as my WCF! Alas, you’ll have to decide whether or not you want to root for the team that plays a lot of guys who work really hard or the team that works really hard and plays a ton of guys. Despite the Warriors having the superstar factor, the Nuggets just have too many legs.

DeGama: Nuggets in 6. Let this be a lesson to Golden State: when you have chance to add Paul Pierce to make a playoff run, you do it, particularly at the very reasonable cost of Harrison Barnes. I have a basketball nerd crush on Steph Curry but the Warriors look like a regular season wonder to me. Denver’s injuries will make this series closer than it should but but Golden State’s defense is going to be exposed.


Robb: Grizz in 6. I don’t trust Vinny Del Negro and I do trust the Grizzlies defense.

Pina: Grizz in 7. I already forget my prediction. I want to see these teams battle so badly.

Jackson: Grizz in 7. This series will prove that better players are better players even of they are worse athletes.

DeGama: Grizz in 7. There’s no non-Boston series I’m looking forward to more than this one. I like Memphis’ frontcourt over the Clippers, assuming L.A. isn’t able to clog up the paint against a Grizzlies team that could struggle with their perimeter shooting. I think CP3 takes a couple of games away from the Grizz down the stretch but Memphis ends up winning the paint and the series.



Robb: Celtics over Pacers in 7

Pina: Celtics over Pacers in 6

Jackson: Celtics over Pacers in 6

DeGama: Pacers over Celtics in 7

Robb: Heat over Bulls in 6

Pina: Heat over Nets in 5

Jackson: Heat over Bulls in 5

DeGama: Heat over Nets in 5



Robb: Thunder over Grizzlies in 7

Pina: Grizzlies over Thunder in 6

Jackson: Grizzlies over Rockets in 6

DeGama: Thunder over Grizzlies in 7.

Robb: Spurs over Nuggets in 6

Pina: Spurs over Nuggets in 7

Jackson: Spurs over Nuggets in 6

DeGama: Spurs over Nuggets in 6



Robb: Heat over Celtics in 7

Pina: Heat over Celtics in 5

Jackson: Heat over Celtics in 5

DeGama: Heat over Pacers in 5



Robb: Thunder over Spurs in 6

DeGama: Thunder over Spurs in 7

Pina: Spurs over Thunder in 6



Robb: Thunder over Heat in 7

DeGama: Heat over Thunder in 7

Pina: Heat over Spurs in 6

The following two tabs change content below.

Brian Robb

Brian Robb co-founded CelticsHub in 2009 and is the currently editor-in-chief. He is a producer and reporter at 98.5 The Sports Hub in Boston and also contributes to Boston.com and Bleacher Report among other outlets.
Share →
  • Frank A

    It’s simple. If the celtics defense that played from January 2 to late March shows up we will win. I’m a little nervous about some of these new guys understanding the rotations.

  • jman

    Perimeter defense is a necessity in this series. If Bradley, Lee, Pierce and Green don't control the perimeter then we're screwed. Series won't last 5 games. If the half-court offense doesn't go through Kg then again, we're screwed. And the most important of all is Rebounds. Without 2nd chance shots and without limiting their 2nd chance shots, we're screwed. But this will be a testament that's for sure for if we win this series, Miami will lose against us for NY is just another version of Miami.

    My main concern though and you'll all hate me for this is hopefully this will be a real series not a Wwf series. 5 on 5 will be nice not 5 on 8 like I'm predicting.

  • Skip Bayless picked the C's to win against the knicks in the first round in 6!

    • tbunny

      I wish I didn't know that.

  • justin v

    Bruce Bowen said he has the C’s in 6.

  • hydrofluoric

    Regarding the Celtics

    1. I don't think you'll see too many people claiming that the Knicks are going to have it easy vs. the Celtics. It's easy for locker-room material and lines like "there are countless … who are counting out the Celtics." In reality, almost all of those predictions qualify their pick with "but you can never count out the Celtics." It's just that the Knicks are a favorite for a reason.

    2. KG and Paul Pierce didn't play together for much of the last six weeks, but how is that supposed to make us feel confident going into the playoffs? There could be rust, small chemistry issues, major rotation issues… a lot of us have questioned Doc's performance this year, and KG's injury could play a HUGE role in helping us to lose this series. And this year's team never put together a string of 10 to 15 games where they just blew their opponents off the floor. I'm skeptical about that ability coming out in the playoffs.

    3. While the Celtics are nominally healthier than the Knicks, the Knicks have played much, much better down the stretch of the season *despite* that gap in health. They pasted Indiana (who were still playing for the 2-seed) by 10 points running Chris Copeland as their center. The Celtics kind of fell apart with their injury woes, the Knicks just kept rolling. That should worry us.

    4. That said… I can't pick against these Celtics.

    Regarding general predictions

    1. I simply can't envision a scenario where GSW loses elimination Game 6 at home to the Nuggets. If the Nuggets win, it's in 5 or 7.

    2. I feel like a lot of y'all are sleeping on Atlanta. I don't think they'll win, but trading Joe Johnson was like Memphis trading Rudy Gay; it was a straight up good move in the short- AND long-term. Remember, the same core, less Joe Johnson, took Derrick Rose's Bulls (in Rose's MVP year) to 6.

    3. EVERYONE predicted Spurs to win 2 rounds?! I guess if you think the Celtics have been hiding their true powers for the playoffs, then you must think the same of the Spurs, who have looked almost as bad as the Celtics in the last X weeks. Bill Simmons pointed out that the refs will give the Lakers every single call, without question. Plus, Tony Parker shot 1-10 in the last meeting thanks to Dwight Howard's paint protection. That series could go 7 IMO, and the Nuggets certainly have the horses to tire the Spurs out, too. I love Pop, but his team is the most vulnerable big seed IMO. How did so many of you guys pick the Spurs to eliminate the Nuggets in Game 6 in Denver?!

  • nba is fixed

    celtics in the conference finals without Rondo
    d d d

    • tbunny

      I know it's crazy right?

      Don't you have a MeloMVP comment to write somewhere?

  • LarryLowLife

    lol… so the Celtics are gonna win four of the next five now huh… lol… you guys are all insane

  • I like the helpful info you provide in your articles.
    I’ll bookmark your weblog and check again here regularly. I am quite certain I will learn many new stuff right here! Best of luck for the next!

  • Unquestionably imagine that that you said. Your favourite reason seemed to be on the net the simplest factor
    to take into accout of. I say to you, I definitely get irked while people think about issues that they plainly do
    not recognize about. You managed to hit the nail upon the highest as well as outlined out the entire thing without having side-effects , people
    can take a signal. Will likely be again to get more.